We Five -You Were on My Mind 1966 “You Were on My Mind” is a popular song written by Sylvia Fricker in 1961. It was originally recorded by Ian & Sylvia, but better known versions were recorded by We Five and Crispian St. Peters. The song was written in a bathtub in a suite at the Hotel Earle in Greenwich Village. Fricker wrote it—her first composition—in the bathroom because “it was the only place ... the cockroaches would not go”. In 1965, the song was covered in an up-tempo version, with sligh